I just got back from NAR NXT last week and had some wonderful meetings and conversations. I am quite inclined to be favorable to NAR, especially the team that Nykia Wright has assembled. They are taking some positive steps, and I wish them a lot of luck.

Then... the "volunteer leadership" goes and does this:

The National Association of REALTORS®’ Multiple Listing Issues and Policies Committee approved four MLS policy recommendations on Sunday during NAR NXT 2026 in continuing to address the evolving MLS landscape.
The four changes focus on strengthening copyright protections for MLS listing content, providing MLSs with greater flexibility to establish local data feed requirements, clarifying permitted uses of MLS data and updating qualifications for service on NAR’s MLS Committee.

The substance of these policies range from amusing to disastrous. The good news comes from Real Estate News, quoting NAR saying that they want to "promote the MLS's independent decision-making." Well, the best thing that be said about these new policies is that the MLS can ignore them.

Let's dig into the four new updates and see for ourselves, shall we?

The Actual Policy Language

Now, I do not have whatever the Board of Directors ultimately passed and the revisions to the MLS Handbook are not yet published, as far as I know. But I do have the language from the Committee Recommendations – thank you Dear Readers, you know who you are.

I will quote liberally from them, but do keep in mind that these may not be final policy language.

The Amusing

First up, Recommendation #1:

To adopt a new MLS Policy Statement clearly authorizing and establishing the local discretion of an MLS to create MLS Data Feed Services that address demands for MLS data feeds by MLS Participants needing to meet locally establish criteria.
(new) MLS Policy Statement XX – MLS Data Feed Services
An MLS has discretionary authority to develop local Data Feed Services when providing data feeds to MLS Participants (and Subscribers, where authorized) that includes the listing content of other MLS Participants. This can include, but is not limited to, data feeds for IDX, VOW, BBO and syndication, provided an MLS Participant (and Subscriber, where authorized) can still access MLS listing content through the MLS platform or through other MLS approved means (e.g. web API,) and share it with their clients and customers consistent with local MLS Participation.
An MLS may also establish local eligibility requirements and licensing for MLS Data Feed Services that require reasonable, objective, and equally applied criteria to all Participants seeking MLS Data Feed Services.
Local eligibility requirements may consider items including, but not limited to, contribution of listing content to the MLS, transactional activity as an agent or recognized non-agent of a buyer or seller, technical readiness, cyber security and compliance, and the execution of applicable agreements.
An MLS must act on requests for MLS Data Feed Services within its ordinary processing timeframes.
Nothing in this Policy Statement limits a Participant’s right to access MLS listing content through the MLS platform or other approved systems or to receive a data feed of the Participant’s own listing content. O

Given that we have ostensibly REALTOR MLSs like Unlock and Realtracs already creating data feeds, establishing local eligibility requirements, charging vastly different fees, and such... I suppose there's no harm in NAR "giving MLSs more flexibility."

I mean, it's a bit like setting a 10pm curfew for your 23-year old daughter who makes her own money, then texting her at 2am saying, "Hey, you can stay out longer if you want." I guess? If it makes you feel better, go ahead and do it. The rest of us will simply chuckle at the hapless dad giving retroactive permission to his grown-ass daughter.

One does wonder what would happen if an MLS establishes local eligibility requirements that are not "equally applied criteria" (for example). What's NAR gonna do about it? The data recipients (or someone denied a feed) would get upset and might sue, but what is NAR going to do exactly if the MLS decides to do something they don't like?

So this policy, which is labeled as Optional, is more amusing than anything else.